When the Accused Runs the Company: Executive and C-Suite Investigations
What Employers Need to Know
|
Independence the org chart cannot provide.
The defining feature of an executive investigation is that the org chart is the problem. The head of HR reports to the accused, or to the accused’s ally; in-house counsel advises the company the accused personifies; and every internal investigator’s career sits within the accused’s reach. No individual integrity cures this, so the structure itself must supply the independence. That means escalation above the accused whether this is to the board, its audit or a special committee, or the independent directors, depending on severity and governance structure. It means outside counsel that is engaged by the oversight body, reporting to the oversight body, and given a mandate documented at the outset. Complaint channels deserve advance attention too. If every road leads through the executive's office, the complaint about the executive never arrives. Consider now, before the complaint arrives, whether there is a reporting structure for complaints regarding high-ranking individuals in place.
The collateral workstreams.
While the investigation proceeds, a second track of questions runs alongside it. Unmanaged, they can do as much damage as the underlying conduct. You should read the employment agreement early and take note: what does “cause” actually require and what process does it demand. Notify the D&O and EPLI carriers on the timelines that the policies demand and know indemnification and advancement obligations before the executive raises them. For public companies and regulated entities, disclosure analysis starts immediately.
Speed, secrecy, and the interim question.
In these types of investigations, confidentiality is both more critical and more difficult, because the interviewees are senior, connected, and talkative. Speed matters more, not less. An organization visibly investigating its own leader is an organization holding its breath, and every week of drift invites risk. There’s also the interim question about whether the executive can remain in their role during the investigation, which has no formulaic answer. It does, however, have a formulaic error: leaving an accused executive in unsupervised command of the very people about to be interviewed. Where full leave is untenable, structured alternatives like recusal from decisions touching the participants, a monitoring arrangement, or temporarily rerouted reporting lines, must be real, documented, and enforced.
How can employers prepare now for establishing a process when it’s the executive or member of the C-suite at the center of the investigation?
- Build the escalation path now. Develop a board-level channel for complaints implicating senior executives, written into policy and the hotline configuration.
- Identify a small list of outside counsel for executive matters. Identify a firm without meaningful ties to the management team before the matter that needs them.
- Inventory executive employment agreements for “cause” definitions, process requirements, and equity consequences, so the contract is readily understood before without delay.
- Prepare the parallel-workstream checklist to include carriers, indemnification, disclosure, sponsor and lender obligations, and communications and assign the owners in advance.
Next installment: AI as an investigator’s tool, as the misconduct itself, and the evidence that can no longer be taken at face value.
The Investigation Roadmap: A Twelve-Part Series for Employers
This is an installment of the Investigation Roadmap, a twelve-part Vorys at Work series on workplace investigations. It is published weekly and walks through the full life of a workplace investigation, from the moment a complaint lands to the day the file becomes an exhibit.