Newsroom icon Authored article

Ohio Weighs Post-Production Costs, Royalty Calculations

Oil and Gas Journal

Greg Russell, Pete Lusenhop and Steven Chang, attorneys in the Vorys Columbus office, co-authored an article for the June 2015 edition of the Oil and Gas Journal titled “Ohio Weighs Post-Production Costs, Royalty Calculations.”  The article provided an in-depth look at how the competing “at-the-well” and “marketable product” approaches square with Ohio contract law, and how Ohio courts, including the Ohio Supreme Court, may view post-production cost deductions.

The article states:

“Post-production cost deductions are a common source of royalty litigation. Local lease-interpretation rules determine whether particular deductions are proper and defensible in court. Different jurisdictions, however, follow different rules to different ends.

Historically, a lease calling for a royalty based on the value of production at the wellhead has allowed the lessee to net-back post-production costs when determining the value of production upon which royalty calculations are based.

A countervailing theory, however, has been urged in some jurisdictions which requires the lessee to bear the costs of converting natural gas extracted at the wellhead into a marketable condition.  This theory reasons that production— the sole responsibility of the lessee— was not complete until the gas was in a form in which it could be sold.

Under the “marketable product” theory, the lessee alone bears the cost of common post-production expenses for treating, compressing, dehydrating, and in some states, transporting oil and gas to a viable market.

Ohio has a long history of oil and gas production stretching back to the 19th Century. Recently, however, the Utica shale has become a major contributor to US oil and gas production. Yet the state has not directly addressed whether it follows the “at-the-well” approach or some version of the “marketable product” theory. The Supreme Court of Ohio, however, may rule on the dilemma soon. A federal court certified this question to the Supreme Court of Ohio on April 1, 2015.”

To read the entire article, visit the Oil and Gas Journal website. (Subscription required).

Related Professionals

Related Industries

Jump to Page